Why we chose our Warhammer armies: voices from the MMG community
Share
Our army guides tell you what is in each box and what to add next. They can't tell you what it feels like to pick an army and stick with it. So we asked the MMG community.
Players sent us 20 army submissions across Warhammer 40,000, Age of Sigmar and The Old World. Some people told us about more than one army. That is not a survey of what is popular, and nobody's answer is a verdict on how good an army is. It is a set of honest reasons from people who have spent real time with their models, which is exactly what helps when you are trying to choose your own.
If you are choosing now, keep our guides open alongside this: Which Warhammer 40K army should I play?, Which Age of Sigmar army should I play? and Which Old World army should I play?
It often starts with one model
Several answers started with a particular miniature.
Robin found the Raven Guard in 2008, while serving in Afghanistan, through Kayvaan Shrike's original metal miniature in White Dwarf. Robin still names Shrike as a favourite character: βheβs the reason I fell in love with the Raven Guard.β
In The Old World, both Warriors of Chaos players reached for the same model. David waited for modern plastics before starting the game: βThe Chaos Lord on Dragon is one of my favourite models GW has ever released.β Smurf Ben, asked for a favourite melee hitter, answered: βChaos lord on dragon...obviouslyβ.
Sometimes it is a unit rather than a hero. Kieran M on the T'au Broadside: βJust an amazing model, with a ridiculously sized gun for the suit holding it.β Kinser on the Sisters of Battle's Exorcist tank: βthe embodiment of Gothic space tanksβ.

If one model keeps pulling you back, that is a perfectly good reason to choose an army. Our guides flag where the famous models are not in the starter box, so you know what you are buying.
Sometimes the reason is simple
Some of our favourite answers were the shortest. Asked what made them pick their army:
- Seraphon, from a player who asked to stay anonymous: βCause Dinosaurs!β
- Leagues of Votann, from Austin D-W: βDwarves Baby!!β
- Astra Militarum, from another anonymous player: βHumansβ

And some armies arrive by accident. Smurf Ben's Orks came out of an old 40K starter box: βNobody else wanted them from the 5th edition Blackreach box so I bought them off my mates for dead cheap!β
The lore, or your own history
For some players the story comes first. Steff thinks the Stormcast Eternals' lore has improved a lot since the first edition, and likes that the current story shows the Stormcast βslowly lose their minds as they fight and die over and over again.β
Others want room to invent. One Empire player picked the army partly because it let them set much of the official lore aside: βI prefer the old world to be a sandbox to make my own storiesβ. Robin went the same way in 40K, creating a Raven Guard successor Chapter, the Peregrine Talons.
If you like writing your own background, look for armies with plenty of customisation: the Empire of Man, Space Marine Chapters and Chaos warbands all leave lots of room.
A playstyle that suits you
Some players changed army because the old one didn't suit how they wanted to play. Andy Giddings switched in The Old World: βI used to play dwarfs - they were very slow and precise. Beastmen gave me the chance to go nuts and charge stuff!β
Smurf Ben has found a way of playing Warriors of Chaos that keeps a complicated game manageable. This is how he chooses to run his force, not a limit on what the army can do: βWoC allows me to reduce this complexity by only participating in 2 phases of the game, movement and combat.β
Jacob Potter summed up Bretonnia in five words: βHitting hard and fast firstβ.
These are how individual players enjoy their armies, not rules for how an army must be played. But if one of them sounds like you, it is worth reading that army's entry in the guides.
Favourite units and memorable nonsense
We asked about favourite fighters, shooters and characters. The answers were not always about winning.
Adi Richards recalls one game where a Tomb Kings scorpion earned its place: βOne of mine killed an orc general in one hit and tied up 16 orc boys for 4 turns!β
One Imperial Knights player recalls a Canis Rex moment from a past game: βA memorable moment was dealing 90 damage to Dante in melee during 10th editionβ.
Asked for a favourite melee unit, one Astra Militarum player replied: βWhatβs melee?β
And Tom's favourite Ogor Mawtribes fighters are the Gnoblars, because βtheyβre hilariously badβ.
Favourite units are about enjoyment, not about which unit is best. Points and rules change; the stories stay.
The best advice we got
The anonymous Seraphon player had one piece of advice for anyone starting the army, and it is not bad advice for any army: βRule of cool is the only advice with this army!β
Pick the models you want on your desk, check what is in the box, and build from there. Our guides will help with the second part.
Tell us about your army
The survey is still open, and we will keep adding player voices to our faction guides. If you play Warhammer 40,000, Age of Sigmar or The Old World, tell us why you picked your army. You choose whether we credit you by name, quote you anonymously or use your answer as background only.